Homeowner guide

Roof decking change orders: what to agree on before tear-off

Before roof tear-off, agree in writing on how concealed decking damage will be documented, priced, and approved. Ask what the base estimate includes, which unit applies to extra work, and who can authorize it. A change order should connect the added work to visible evidence and an agreed price.

Why can the decking quantity change?

Shingles and underlayment cover the roof deck, so an inspection cannot always show every concealed condition. Accessible attic observations can help, but they do not expose the full top surface. After tear-off, the contractor may find damaged material that was not visible earlier.

That uncertainty should be part of the estimate conversation. Ask what can be assessed before work and what will remain unknown until the covering comes off. A clear process is more useful than a verbal promise that there will be no surprises.

Set these terms before work starts

  • Included quantity: Is any decking replacement included in the base price? Record the material and unit.
  • Extra-work rate: Is additional work priced per sheet, square foot, board, or another unit? Ask whether labor and disposal are included.
  • Evidence: Request a location photo and a close-up showing the condition before replacement.
  • Approval: Name the person who can approve extra work and how they will be contacted during the job.
  • Weather protection: Agree on how the exposed area will be protected while a decision is being made.

A sheet price alone can still be ambiguous. Confirm the product, thickness or specification, and whether the rate covers removal, installation, fasteners, and disposal. Structural framing repair should be distinguished from replacement of roof sheathing.

Use this change-order record

FieldWhat to record
LocationA roof-plane label and photos tied to that area
ConditionWhat was found and why the proposed work is needed
Material and unitExact material and whether priced per sheet, area, or board
Quantity and rateAdded quantity multiplied by the agreed installed rate
Included allowanceAny quantity or credit already included in the contract
Approval and timingWho agreed, when, and any effect on completion

A calculation example without an invented market price

Suppose a hypothetical contract includes two sheets and the final approved total is five sheets of the same specified material. If the contract charges only for sheets beyond the included quantity, the added quantity is three. The additional charge is three multiplied by the agreed installed rate.

That calculation only applies when those are the contract terms. Some estimates contain no included quantity; others treat an allowance as a money credit. Resolve that difference before signing rather than assuming every contractor uses the same method.

What if the extra work is much larger than expected?

Ask for an updated scope before work expands beyond the agreed process. Widespread replacement, framing defects, or a different deck assembly can be a different decision from a few localized sheets. Ask what was found, which work is necessary now, and which parts of the original price remain unchanged.

Do not step onto an exposed roof to inspect it yourself. Use photos, an explanation from the contractor, and appropriate professional advice if a structural question remains unresolved.

What should I keep at the end?

Save the original estimate, approved changes, location photos, and final quantity together. Ask the final invoice to distinguish the original contract amount from approved additions. The records should let you follow how the scope changed without reconstructing a series of phone conversations.

Request a replacement inspection and ask North Indy Roof Co. to explain the decking terms before the job is scheduled. This worksheet is a construction-planning aid, not legal advice or a replacement for your contract.

Technical background: GAF’s bulletin on complete steep-slope roof tear-offs explains why exposing the existing assembly helps assess deficient decking. Pricing examples here use hypothetical quantities, not local price claims.

Get a documented next step.

Tell us what is happening at your North Indy home. We perform roofing inspections, repairs, and replacement services.